Huggg

What bad gifts teach us: 4 of the worst work gifts, and what to do instead

November 17, 2026 · Gifting, Christmas

A Marmite cookbook, a £5 voucher after five years and a drill with terrible timing. Our panel picks apart four real worst work gifts and shares what to do instead.

Everyone's got a bad gift story. The cookbook built around a food you can't stand. The voucher that works out at a pound a year. The certificate you have to print out yourself.

For our 5th November webinar, we asked everyone who registered to send in the worst work gift they'd ever had. Then we put four of them in front of three people who sort employee gifting for a living:

  • Jane Dennis, Head of Wellbeing and Workplace Manager at Oakland
  • Sam Whitwham, People Experience and Insight Partner at Alzheimer's Research UK
  • Beca Floyd, Engagement and Development Manager at Dermalogica
  • Hosted by Lewis Quick, Commercial Director at Huggg

As Lewis said at the start, there's no such thing as a truly bad gift. Every one of these came from someone trying to do something nice. But not every gift lands, and the ones that miss teach you a lot.

Watch the What bad gifts teach us webinar recording on YouTube

Watch the full 29-minute recording on YouTube, or read the highlights below.

Quick answer: why do work gifts go wrong? Most bad work gifts fail in one of three ways. They assume everyone has the same taste, they make the value painfully obvious, or they ignore what's going on in the person's life. Choice, a personal message and good timing fix most of it.

1. The Marmite cookbook: one size never fits all

A Christmas present from the CEO. The person who got it hates Marmite.

The brand's own slogan says you either love it or hate it. If the CEO gave the same book to the whole company, it was guaranteed to miss for a big chunk of people.

Jane called it "very niche". Any gift going to lots of people needs to work for nearly all of them, and a cookbook assumes everyone cooks in the first place.

Sam has just redesigned how Alzheimer's Research UK recognises its people, with hackathons and interviews across the charity. One finding came through louder than the rest: "One size will never fit all, and personal preference is really, really important." That's why they now let people choose from a range of options within a set budget.

Beca sees the same thing at Dermalogica, where 250 people work across lots of different places. One of their most popular company-wide gifts was popcorn where everyone picked their own two flavours. Everyone got a similar gift, but everyone got to choose.

What to do instead:

  • Send everyone the same budget, not the same thing
  • Let people pick the gift (or the flavour, or the shop) themselves
  • If you do pick one gift for everyone, make sure it's something almost nobody would turn down

2. A £5 Matalan voucher after five years: it's the proportion, not the price

This one was a leaving gift after five years with the company.

For Jane, the amount says "we don't care" before the envelope's even open. Someone who's given you five years deserves a bit more thought.

Sam was careful to point out that not every organisation can afford big gifts, and that's fine. The problem is proportion. A small voucher invites people to do the maths, and the maths here is grim: "So my five years is worth, like, a quid every 365 days?"

If £5 is the budget, Sam would spend it differently. Take them to a coffee shop. Talk about their five years and what's next. Make it about the person, not the voucher.

Beca agreed. A £5 bunch of flowers and a card the whole team had written in would have landed better. As she put it, a £5 voucher "feels like they've missed a digit off".

What long service can look like: Dermalogica gives long-serving people a branded award, a cash reward and a Huggg gift. With staff who've reached 30 and 35 years, and two more hitting 20 years this Christmas, they get plenty of practice.

3. A PDF certificate: a moment, not a file

The certificate was the whole gift. And it arrived as a PDF.

Sam has used values certificates in previous roles, so the idea isn't the problem. It's the effort. Print it out. Get colleagues to sign it. Add a few personal messages.

At Oakland, Jane's team prints and laminates certificates and hands them out in front of the whole company. The most recent one was for a colleague who'd won a trip to China. Same piece of paper, completely different moment.

What to do instead:

  • Make it physical, and hand it over in person
  • Get the team to add their own messages
  • If budget is tight, attach a small treat, like a coffee, so there's something to enjoy as well as read

4. An electric drill, the day after a house purchase fell through: timing is everything

Beca was generous on this one. The gift was bought in good faith for a new home. The timing was just horribly unlucky.

Sam pointed out that moving house is one of the most stressful things people go through, and when emotions are running high, anything that goes wrong feels bigger. Every time they looked at that drill, they'd remember the house they didn't get.

A better move? Give them the afternoon off and a cinema or spa voucher to switch off. Then save the drill for the housewarming.

Why life moments matter as much as work wins

Recognition usually means recognising performance. The panel argued that the moments outside work often matter more.

Oakland marks engagements, weddings and new babies. New parents get a romper printed with one of the company's values, plus a voucher, so they can spend it however they need to.

Beca has been at Dermalogica for 16 years and came back from maternity leave four months ago. What stays with her isn't the gifts themselves:

"It doesn't actually matter what it is you sent me. You know, sometimes I can't even remember what was sent on some things. But the fact that you were thought about and someone sent it to you is the most important thing."

She also makes the case for "thinking of you" gifts during harder times, like a bereavement or time off sick. Those are the moments people remember about a job.

The panel's top tips for employee gifting

We asked each panellist for one tip:

  1. Beca: make the message personal: Even if everyone gets the same gift, a heartfelt message can make it feel like it was written for one person.
  2. Jane: give people options: A hamper with wine in it misses everyone who doesn't drink. Think about dietary needs, and have an alternative ready.
  3. Sam: get the timing and context right: The drill is the proof. A good gift at the wrong moment still goes wrong.

And the worst gift is...

The Marmite cookbook. Sam summed up why: coming from the CEO, it's a message about the culture they want. And what it said was, "I don't really know half of my team."

Sorting gifts for your team this Christmas?

We turned the panel's advice into a free gifting checklist: practical steps, a budget calculator and a template for a personal note.

If you'd rather skip the Marmite moment altogether, Gift with Choice lets you set the budget while each person picks the gift they actually want, from 200+ brands. No logins for them, and no guessing for you. See how Huggg works.

Related articles